If your board just opened a renewal with a double-digit increase, you're not alone. Condominium and HOA master policies across Illinois have been getting more expensive for several years, and many boards are now explaining a higher assessment to owners who want to know why.
Some of the reasons are outside your control. Others aren't. Here's what's driving the increases, and what your board can do before the next renewal.
Premiums are rising because buildings cost more to rebuild, insurers pay more for their own reinsurance, severe storms and water claims are more frequent, and fewer carriers are competing for association business. Boards that start early, document their buildings, and attack water losses usually get the best results.
Why premiums are rising
1. Your buildings cost more to rebuild
Your premium is calculated on the building's insured value, which should match what it would cost to rebuild today. Construction labor and materials have risen sharply in recent years, so building values go up at renewal. Even if the insurer's rate stayed flat, a higher value produces a higher premium.
2. Insurers are paying more for reinsurance
Insurance companies buy their own insurance, called reinsurance, to protect against large losses. Reinsurance costs climbed significantly after several years of major catastrophe losses, and insurers pass that cost on in their rates.
3. Severe storms are hitting the Midwest harder
Hail, straight-line winds, and severe thunderstorms are now a major source of property losses in Illinois. Carriers have responded with higher rates, higher wind and hail deductibles, and stricter roof requirements.
4. Water damage claims keep coming
Burst pipes, failed supply lines, leaking water heaters, and unit-to-unit leaks are among the most frequent claims in condominium buildings. They're individually smaller than a fire, but there are a lot of them, and they add up.
5. Your association's own claims
Underwriters look at five years of loss history. A few water claims or one large loss can move your association into a higher price tier or limit which carriers will quote.
6. Older buildings and systems
Vintage courtyard buildings and older high-rises are part of what makes Chicago-area condos appealing. They also come with original plumbing, older electrical systems, and aging roofs that underwriters price carefully.
7. Fewer carriers competing
Some insurers have reduced how much habitational and association business they write, or tightened what they'll accept. Less competition means less pressure on price.
8. Liability and umbrella costs
Larger jury verdicts and legal costs have pushed up liability and umbrella pricing, especially for higher limits.
What boards can do
You can't control reinsurance markets or the weather. These steps are within your control, and they make a real difference in how underwriters see your association.
- Start the renewal 90 to 120 days out. Underwriters need time to inspect and quote. Starting late leaves you with whatever arrives first.
- Update your insurance appraisal. Accurate building values protect you from being underinsured and keep you from paying for value you don't need. See insurance-to-value explained.
- Review your deductibles, and tell owners. A higher deductible can lower the premium, but it shifts more cost to the association or to owners. If you raise it, owners should check the loss assessment coverage on their own HO-6 policies.
- Go after water losses. Leak detection sensors, automatic water shutoff valves, scheduled replacement of supply lines and water heaters, and a winter readiness plan all reduce claims. Some carriers give credit for them.
- Document every upgrade. A newer roof, updated electrical panels, replaced risers, or a new boiler only helps if the underwriter knows about it. Keep dates, invoices, and permits.
- Send a complete submission. A clean package with current values, five years of loss runs, building details, and updates gets better attention than a renewal form with blanks.
- Compare more than one market. An independent agency can take your association to multiple carriers. The right fit for a 12-unit courtyard building is often different from the right fit for a 200-unit high-rise.
Explaining the increase to owners
Owners are more understanding when the board shows its work. A one-page summary that covers what changed (values, rates, deductibles), what the board did to control cost, and what owners should check on their own HO-6 policies goes a long way at the annual meeting.
We'll review your current master policy, building values, and deductibles, and explain your options in language you can take straight to the board.
Request an association reviewThis article is general information, not legal advice. Coverage depends on the terms of each policy and is subject to underwriting approval. Your declaration, bylaws, and association attorney have the final word on your association's obligations.